Advice to other Families having Loved Ones Deceased Overseas.

My Advice and Experience for Families dealing

with the Suspicious Death of a Loved One

Overseas.

Table of Contents

  1. Circumstances of the First Few Days of our Daughter’s murder

  2. Advice for Families Facing Similar Situations

1) Circumstances of the First Few Days of Elly’s murder

Our lovely daughter Elly Rose tragically died overseas in Mozambique on the 9th November 2016. At first it was difficult to believe the news! When we heard that an Australian girl had been found murdered possibly raped our immediate thought was, It can’t be Elly. But confirmation soon arrived: it was her found naked near a toilet block. The shock, disbelief and grief were overwhelming.

Dealing with events overseas is incredibly challenging because information is often delayed, fragmented and difficult to verify. In the early stages it can be hard to know what information is accurate and what can be relied upon. Information often takes a considerable amount of time to arrive and the distance, language barriers and different systems can add further uncertainty.

However in Elly's case we found that the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) ultimately provided the family with the most reliable, consistent and trustworthy information during those difficult early stages. Their support and communication helped us navigate an incredibly complex and distressing situation at a time when clear and dependable information was essential.

Friends came to support us and Nicole, Elly’s mother confirmed with the manager of where Elly was staying that it was our daughter who had died in Mozambique.

As I have mentioned DFAT provided excellent early support keeping us informed of the situation informing us that heavy rains had closed the nearest airport at Inhambane so Elly’s body had to be transported roughly 900 km by road to Maputo for her autopsy which tock 4 days. DFAT kept us updated throughout the journey and informed us that the autopsy was scheduled for 14th November 2016 in Maputo.

DFAT also advised that the Mozambique autopsy may not meet professional standards and suggested a second autopsy in South Africa. Nicole and myself agreed and a second autopsy was performed in South Africa by a forensic pathologist Dr Klepp.

I chose to fly there to retrieve Elly’s body accompanied by my sister and Elly’s boyfriend Luke. DFAT arranged all travel and accommodation and 1Cover travel insurance covered everything including bringing Elly’s body home which was amazing and a very big help when you have so many other things going around in your mind.

At the funeral parlor in South Africa viewing Elly was heartbreaking. Her face showed bruising, abrasions and a swollen lip clear signs of assault. This was extremely difficult for me and my sister and I advise families to carefully consider whether to view their loved one as the image stays with you forever.

Returning home immediately was my biggest regret. In hindsight I should have gone straight to Tofo Mozambique to investigate and gather the trace evidence especially Elly’s clothes she was wearing on the night and to obtain direct answers from authorities and doctors relevant to the investigation.

The AFP told us Mozambique authorities were in control of the investigation as they have total jurisdiction but in reality they were trying to cover up the circumstances of Elly’s death which came out later on with my investigation. Giving statements to AFP should be approached with caution; everything you say becomes evidence.

Elly later had a third autopsy in Melbourne which we were not aware of until the last minute as the coroner here decided to have another autopsy, had we been aware we would not have had the South Africa autopsy. While Mozambique autopsy indicated a violent death by homicide with abundance of packed sand in her airways the Melbourne pathologist concluded “undetermined.” this was a complete contradiction to the Mozambique and South African autopsies and never added up from the outset!!

I rung Dr Klepp on the 20th November only 11 days after Elly’s death as she left her number at the bottom of her preliminary autopsy report and she told me Elly’s airways were packed with sand and that she suspected foul play. However no Australian authorities or anyone from the coroners court contacted Dr Klepp in 2016/17 and I had informed them all about Dr Klepp’s serious conclusion over the phone with me!!

Dr Klepp later in evidence given in the 2023 inquest supported that phone call and states: “the sand was CHOCKABLOCK and it was the worst case of packed sand she had come across in her 44 years”. Dr Klepp also states: “I have seen sand before as gold mines cave in all the time in South Africa”. But there was no follow up by any Australian authorities with Dr Klepp in 2016/17!!!

In fact the AFP misled the family for months by giving the impression that a proper investigation was ongoing in Mozambique when the documentary record later on revealed a very different picture with my Investigation.

Based on my experience I would urge anyone dealing with the AFP to carefully examine all documents, ask questions and seek written confirmation of important information wherever possible. If you are told that a particular action has been taken, an investigation conducted, or inquiries made, meetings taken place ask to see the records for proof, evidence or documentation that support those claims by the AFP keep on their backs at all times. Do not simply accept assurances at “face value”; seek proof and verify the facts for yourself wherever possible with what ever the AFP give you if anything!! My first official letter from the AFP came in March 2019!! Three years after Elly’s murder from the AFP that’s how much they cared!!

It is therefore very importance to independently check the information provided by the AFP and ensuring that important decisions are supported by documentary evidence if they bother to get involved at all!

However it’s also the vital information the AFP are aware of which they don’t disclose to the family and Coroner!!! “It may become a diplomatic issue which you may not be aware of”

I would also encourage families to ask the AFP to clearly explain what tangible outcomes their involvement has “Achieved” for them and to request supporting documentation wherever possible on what they claim they have done for your family. After almost ten years of seeking answers I believe this is reasonable question of the AFP: What tangible outcomes did your involvement “ACHIEVE” for Elly's family or your family if you are faced with these same diabolical circumstances?

From my perspective despite years of correspondence and engagement, the AFP's involvement did not produce the answers, accountability or any investigative outcomes that our family had hoped for. The AFP are all talk and No real action just camouflaging evidence and words in records which are not directly to the point. Offering assurances that they are communicating with the country concerned which have no real outcomes to keep you off there backs which is one area the AFP are very professional at! Mean while the years keep rolling over with no real answers from the Australian authorities.

However as Australia's only law enforcement agency with responsibility it their sworn duty for assisting in serious overseas matters. Elly’s family discovered later there were additional investigative avenues available to the AFP which including a option of submitting a Mutual Assistance Request (MAR) to the Mozambique attorney general. Under the circumstances of Elly’s highly susphious death this should have been considered and sent due to the vital evidence the AFP had obtained in 2016 indicating it was highly probable this was a homicide which was not “disclosed” by the AFP to the Family, Coroner and pathologist. They simply don’t care and don’t want to become involved directly with another country!!

If you do not receive a response from the AFP continue following up and keep a record of all correspondence. Throughout my dealings with the AFP I regularly sent emails seeking answers and clarification yet I was often met with long delays, incomplete responses or no meaningful response at all. Even my Persistence got me nowhere so it is really a waste of time dealing with the AFP as they keep the family in the dark of the real facts. However if they do give you any information you will need to read between the lines with what they do give you as its all half truths!

Be very careful. Over the years, I discovered that this is one area in which the AFP are particularly skilled at: providing only part of the picture the (Half truths). The evidence and records published on this website demonstrate why it is essential to question everything with the AFP and independently verify what they say or don’t say which in my case was not much as they did not want to be made accountable!!

That is the conclusion I have reached regarding the AFP's efforts based on my own experience over the years with the documentary factual verified evidence presented throughout Elly's case on this website.

You may ask why I have reached that conclusion. In my opinion the AFP has diplomatic obligations and responsibilities that can make it difficult to openly expose or publicly criticise the actions of another country's authorities even where there are serious concerns surrounding the suspected murder of an Australian citizen overseas!! Therefore based on my experience in Elly's case I believe those diplomatic considerations take precedence over transparency and accountability in matters of this serious nature. In the end I believe the AFP looks at the bigger picture in terms of the government's the their broader interests of communication channels with other countries as it is only one family involved!!

Looking back one of the biggest mistakes I made was not being more persistent and demanding documentary proof at every stage. I trusted then AFP in the early stages that the information being provided was complete and accurate. Knowing Elly she would never have accepted vague assurances or unanswered questions form the Australian authorities had our positions been reversed!!

Therefore one of the biggest mistakes I made was to “trust” the AFP from the start!! If you want the full truth and real answers you need to “fully investigate yourself” that is the only way you will find out all the facts if your loved one dies overseas especially in a third world country as they really don’t want to investigate or care as they just cover it up like in Elly’s case. Even if the the country in question concludes its not a suspicious death but you think things don't add up as you will be very surprised with what does get covered up behind the scenes. The Australian authorities don’t want it to be a murder overseas as it then becomes too complicated with another country involved especially if they suspect that country as tried to cover it up!! Which is highly likely in a third world country.

In my experience over the years, what is “NOT SAID” by the AFP (Hidden) can be vital and just as important of what you are factually aware of even with the Melbourne pathologist in Elly’s case who stated he found “NO” sand whatsoever at a meeting with the family!!

( it must be “Strongly Noted”; this meeting with the Melbourne pathologist was all “Recorded” with his consent, Also three AFP officials were in attendance and they clearly stated to the family after I had asked, were the Mozambique Authorities investigating Elly’s death as a homicide, there reply was “YES”) For these reasons I strongly recommend obtaining all relevant documents and record everything when possible, look back over and review the evidence for yourself as you will be surprised what you “initial missed”. if you don’t investigate yourself and go over No one will especially if a third world country is involved!!

Ultimately the evidence published on this website demonstrates why independent scrutiny of what you have been informed under this circumstances is essential!!

Note; Especially In countries with limited investigative capacity families need to take initiative to protect evidence and ensure an accurate investigation for the true answers. Therefore it’s very important you go over yourself to seek the factual answers. The AFP are not trained Homicide detectives and really don’t want to get involved with another country, therefore the truth about that really happened to your loved one will only come from you investigating first hand because you care they don’t!!

2) Advice for Families Facing Similar Situations (Especially in Third World Countries)

  1. Go immediately. Do not rely on AFP instructions. It is very important to take the “first” available flight as arriving sooner increases your chances of obtaining vital evidence. DFAT can assist with urgent visas and logistics. If possible bring someone with you for support.

  2. Respect local authorities. Police may be underpaid or undertrained especially in third world countries, but approaching them respectfully can help gain some cooperation.

  3. Overcome communication barriers. Use translators or local contacts. Record everything you see or hear. Best to set this up before you go over if you can as trust is the biggest worry!! You need to be able to trust what is being translated, is correct and the facts. Record as much as you are able to.

  4. Bring US dollars. Recognized widely; know the exchange rate. Notify your bank to avoid blocked transactions.

  5. Protect all trace evidence this is very IMPORTANT Secure clothing at the time of death, personal items or any physical evidence discreetly. Local authorities may not preserve evidence properly. ALL Third world countries can’t test for DNA from clothing. Therefore in Elly’s case this vital trace evidence was never placed into evidence by the Mozambique authorities because they can’t use the clothing its useless to them but not you, it’s vital and may hold the key to Justice with advancements in DNA testing available today!

  6. Visit doctors. Take notes, request reports and use small rewards if culturally appropriate to gain cooperation. But be very discreet and carful adopting this approach. However in my case it did prove effect at times in obtaining important evidence and information.

  7. Document the crime scene. Take photos of the scene and surrounding areas. Collect trace evidence where possible (offer rewards). Go to the hospital and speak to the doctors taking notes and record if possible.

  8. Be careful with your money. Locals may exploit wealth as in third world countries as they think everyone from overseas is wealthy so stay focused with things happening around you.

  9. Take initiative. Foreign family members often have more access and influence. (offer rewards) Use this with respect to gather evidence and information.

  10. Involve DFAT carefully. Share limited information only what you need to as they may inform the AFP, who often limit cooperation as they don’t want to be made accountable!! The AFP will not want you to go and will warn you about going. In some remote areas especially in Africa it is dangerous so if you go be very careful. With my experience the locals in Tofo were friendly and its really the only way you will find the answers by going over first hand and as soon as possible “don't delay”. Any Homicide Detective will say the initial crime scene and the very first few days that follow are the most important to obtain the answers and trace evidence.

  11. Consider a private investigator. Experienced investigators like Mr. Charlie Bezzina can help gather early evidence or give you professional guidance. If I had my time over and I knew what I know today I would have been on that very “first flight” over and with someone that had homicide experience however this would have been difficult with such short notice.

  12. Understand investigative differences. In countries with competent police, strict protocols limit access. I would say you need to respect there protocols if they have trained homicide detectives on your case as this is what you want. In third world countries, acting quickly may make the difference between justice and no answers as their standards are poor. However be respectful at all times this is difficult but it’s the best way for some cooperation.

Coroner’s inquest advice:

  • This is Very Important:
    Only one family member needs legal representation as it is important to maintain direct communication with the coroner’s assistant who in Victoria is from the Victorian state police. It is essential to clarify to the court who is the primary family representative whether the mother or the father. The parent who is not the primary legal representative can still then contact the coroner’s assistant directly at anytime. Failing to make this clarification to the coroner can result in losing the right to communicate with the court directly. I experienced this myself as I still wanted direct contact with the coroner’s assistant but if you Both have legal representation you can lose that right. Therefore inform the court with an official letter directly to the coroner concerned that only one of you has legal representation.

  • The coroner runs and controls the inquest, “NOT YOU”. Any requests or submissions should be made formally in writing and must stick strictly to the facts. Keep all letters and communications focused on verified facts only.

  • Witnesses for the inquest were a “MAJOR” problem for Elly’s family as we were not allowed all the “relevant witnesses” we wanted!! The coroner can influence the outcome by deciding which witnesses to call this is not under “your control”, only the coroner’s. However you can object to the exclusion of a witness and if your reasons are valid the coroner may reconsider and allow the witness to appear. This happened in Elly’s case.

  • If the inquest is held at the Victorian Coroners Court it would not be in your best interests to blame or criticize doctors from the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine (VIFM). Keep all submissions focused strictly on the facts of the case especially the cause and manner of death. Avoid complaints about the AFP, other authorities or any court connected personnel, indirectly doctors included as from my experience this is a waste of time the coroner is not interested in these issues and it is not the court’s role to handle complaints, as I was directly told by Mr Cain the coroner that the Family concerns with the AFP falls outside the court’s jurisdiction!! Submitting complaints to the coroner’s court I found is therefore a complete waste of time!! (focus only on “cause and manner” of death)

Key principle: If a loved one dies overseas especially in a third world country: question everyone and take responsibility for your own investigation do not fully trust any authorities. DFAT can provide logistical support but the AFP may not act in your best interest!!

Acknowledgements

  • Mr. Charlie Bezzina, retired Melbourne Homicide detective, pro bono advice since 2018.

  • Hall & Wilcox Lawyers, pro bono support, especially for the inquest.

  • 1Cover Travel Insurance, excellent support for travel, accommodation, and returning Elly’s body.

Paul Warren